Skip to content
BrightLocal vs

“The value I’m finding in BrightLocal exceeds what was available in Yext”

Mary Mangold
Wild Web West
Google
4.8
366 Reviews
G2
4.6
228 Reviews
Capterra
4.8
281 Reviews
Trustpilot
4.6
752 Reviews

How BrightLocal’s Yext Replacement Service works

Switching from Yext can save you thousands a year. Take control of your listings with BrightLocal.
01

We audit your current Yext listings

We ensure they’re accurate and claim your most important listings. Giving you complete ownership.

02

We build and clean permanent citations

We identify where you need new listings and submit them to key data aggregators.

03

Start managing in BrightLocal

You can then instantly sync and update your business listings with Active Sync. Plus, you get access to our platform and insights.

CASE STUDY
“We’ve made changes and have seen near immediate results, sometimes seeing the change within 15-30 minutes.”
Yext was becoming increasingly expensive for Arkansas Baptist Children & Family Ministries, and each renewal quote would continue to climb. The Yext platform was designed more for a single, identical organization with multiple branches, like a chain of restaurants, and didn’t offer the customization needed for each of the ministry’s locations.
$6,000
Saved annually
head speech bubble chat
BRIGHTLOCAL VS YEXT

See why businesses choose BrightLocal over Yext

While Yext focuses on enterprise businesses, BrightLocal is built for the local experts: small businesses and agencies. We pair affordable, high-impact listings management with the friendliest support in the industry. It’s your data, we just give you the best seat in the house to manage it.
BrightLocal
YEXT

Custom citation building

Build citations with a low cost one time fee. No ongoing subscription. And only pay per citation.
BrightLocal
$2-3.20 /site (once)
Build the citations you need, at a cost that works for you.
Pay once, no recurring fees.
When you build your listings, you truly own them.
YEXT
$499 /year
Yext only offers ongoing subscriptions with set packages.
It’s expensive, and you can’t choose the directories you want or need.

Own your listings forever and manage listings

Ongoing management of listings without breaking the bank.
BrightLocal
Your listings are yours, and you can update them all from our platform.
You get all your account details and logins.
YEXT
You only lease your listings from Yext.
They aren’t yours.
Yext owns your account details.

Local rank tracking

Designed to track your online visibility, rather than just report on your listings.
BrightLocal
Put your rankings on the map and discover how your customers find you.
YEXT
Yext’s reporting features provide updates on how they’re doing, rather than how you’re doing.

Built for SMBs and Agencies

Yext focuses on larger multi-location and enterprise bands. BrightLocal is built to help SMBs and agencies succeed.
BrightLocal
Get real support from real people to help your business win in local search.
Features built to help SMBs and agencies grow.
YEXT
Yext is focused on helping the big multi-location companies.

Local SEO Services

Unlock your new SEO team with BrightLocal.
BrightLocal
Not got the time to do the work? We can help get your business found with our fully-managed services.
YEXT
Yext doesn’t offer any services. It’s just an automated platform.
SAVINGS THAT MATTER

Gain control over your listings and your budget

BrightLocal’s service guarantees that all updates to your listings are yours, unlike Yext’s ongoing subscription fees. Save nearly 50% annually with support and reporting included:

BrightLocal Yext Replacement Service: $250 per location

Comparable Yext service: $499 per location

Unlock an average of $1,450 in savings per location over 5 years and free up spend for your brand elsewhere. For 30 locations, that’s a saving of $43,500 over 5 years (or $8,700 annually)!

Save

~ 20 %

per annum

(yep, really)

THE ALL-IN-ONE PLATFORM

Go beyond automated listings

Yext offers a set of inflexible listing solutions alongside generic marketing tools. BrightLocal is specifically created to help businesses with their local SEO. From auditing to tracking visibility and all the way through to taking actions.
  • Track local rankings
  • Build citations, get reviews, and uncover insights
  • Get the help you need to do the work
  • Automation is powerful, but not perfect. We combine API syncing with manual checks.
hand support button push action
AN EXPERT TEAM, ON HAND

Real people, real support

We pride ourselves on the human touch. Our customer support team are experts in local SEO who are here to help you get the most out of your account.
  • Our support is available in multiple time zones
  • Talk to a real person to get support
  • In-depth knowledge and a specialized Academy to help you succeed
Feature image
Team collaboration
SWITCH AND SAVE

Seamless transition with our expert team

If you’re looking to make the switch, and save big, we can help. BrightLocal offers a tailored replacement service to help make it easier. Don’t worry about losing any of your listings in the process.

Significantly lower costs and instant updates

Improved visibility and transparency

Greater customization and flexibility

OUR SOFTWARE PLATFORM

A true all-in-one solution for local SEO

BrightLocal is the only local SEO platform that truly offers everything you need in one place. Track, manage, and grow in online search.

Track your presence

Audit your location’s optimization and keep on top of your visibility.

Custom-built tools for auditing and reporting

Over 16 years of local search and location data

Feature image

Manage your SEO

Monitor reviews, build citations, track listings, find leads, and get insights on what to do next.

Flexible solutions for small businesses

White-labeling available for agencies

Feature image

Grow your business

Take action right in the platform or work with our fully-managed local SEO services to get found.

Know exactly what you need to do

Tailored recommendations for your business

Feature image

Additional features and tools

Two local rank tracking solutions

Local Rank Tracker and Local Search Grid cover every aspect of local rankings.

Review management

Monitor, respond and generate reviews in one platform.

Build the citations you need

Our in-house team of citation builders help you build, fix, and claim the citations your business needs.

White-label solutions

We make it simple for agencies to white-label their reporting.

Talk to your data

With our MCP Server and API, you can talk to your data and use it how you want.

Automatic review responses

89% of customers expect businesses to respond to reviews. We make that simple.

Manage your listings

Keep on top of all your listings in one tool. Make updates in one centralised place, then push them out.

Agency lead generation tools

Find new leads to help you win more business.

Book your discovery call

Ready to make a smart move?

Book a call with an SEO expert to discuss our Yext Replacement Service. From $250/location:

✓ 25 manually claimed listings
✓ 5 data aggregator submissions
✓ Active Sync instant publishing
✓ Local Search Grid reporting and insights
✓ Managed onboarding and 24/7 support

"I like the control and the communication BrightLocal offers over Yext. I feel like I have more access to my listings and more ability to correct them."

Noelle Geiger

Noelle Geiger

Ameravant

Frequently asked questions

We’ve gathered the most common questions our community asks to help you move forward with total confidence. If your question isn’t there, we’re only a message away.
The biggest difference is ownership. With Yext, you’re essentially renting your listings; if you stop paying, your data often reverts or disappears. With BrightLocal, you own your listings forever. We don’t charge ransom fees, we don’t force you into a one-size-fits-all package, and we give you the actual login details for the listings we build for you.
Yext is great at one thing: instant updates. If your business moves locations every few months or your core info changes weekly, the speed of Yext’s automated API might be worth the high recurring fees. For everyone else, BrightLocal is usually the more cost-effective, long-term choice.
The short answer is that with BrightLocal, you own your listings; with Yext, you rent them.

Unlike Yext’s mandatory recurring subscriptions, BrightLocal allows you to pay a one-time fee for the citations you actually need. Once they are built, they are yours to keep, even if you cancel your plan.

With Yext, if you stop paying, your listings can revert to old, incorrect data or disappear. BrightLocal ensures your data stays intact without a maintenance tax.

Yext forces you into set, expensive packages. BrightLocal lets you hand-pick the specific directories that matter to your business, so you never pay for filler you don’t want.

The bottom line? BrightLocal offers a transparent, pay-as-you-go model that puts you in control of your budget and your data.
You have total control and can choose from 970 sites. We’ll always recommend the power players like Google, Bing, Apple Maps, Yelp, TomTom, Yellowpages, and MapQuest, but Citation Builder also helps you find niche sites specific to your industry and highlights any existing citations that need updating.
That’s right. Our manual citation building is a pay-as-you-go service starting at just $3.20 per listing (or as low as $2 with bulk credits). You pay for the work once, and the listings are yours to keep forever. We don’t believe in charging maintenance fees just to keep your business on the map.

There are only a few instances where you might choose an optional add-on or update:

Data Aggregator Renewals ($120/year): This is optional but recommended. It keeps your data locked across thousands of sources, so it doesn’t get overwritten by outdated info from third parties.

Manual Updates: If you move offices or change your number and don’t have an active sync or aggregator subscription, we charge a simple, one-off fee of $3.20 (or as low as $2 with bulk credits) per listing to manually update your details.

Active Sync (available on our Manage and Grow plans): If you want the best of both worlds—manual ownership plus the ability to push instant updates to key sites like Google, Facebook, and Apple Maps—you can add Active Sync at any time.

Find out more about how we handle location updates here.
No problem.

Unlike traditional API solutions, we don’t charge expensive recurring fees just to hold the door open for those rare times you might need to update a listing.

Instead, we charge a simple, one-off fee of $3.20 (or as low as $2 with bulk credits) for each listing you need to update, and if the listing is managed through a current Data Aggregator Network subscription, there’s no charge at all!
Head over to your Yext Account Settings page to cancel. Your listings will stay active and untouched until your current billing period ends.

To ensure a smooth move to BrightLocal, we recommend reaching out to the Yext support team directly to ask them to release your listings. It’s a good idea to get a quick confirmation from them that this is done before we start migrating you over to us.
It can be a bit messy at first. Some listings might disappear or revert to old, incorrect info. Don’t worry, though; that’s exactly what our Yext Replacement Service is for. We’ll jump in, fix the inconsistencies, and make sure your business is accurately represented on the sites that matter.
We offer a fully managed Yext Replacement Service to enterprise businesses with 20+ locations. We’ll assign you a dedicated Account Manager, and they’ll be there to support you the whole way through the migration from Yext to BrightLocal.

Contact our Sales Team to find out more.
Unlike Yext we offer full flexibility in the choice of sites that you can build listings on. This allows you to build on 100s of sites, or just a select few.

For an equivalent campaign to Yext, the breakdown would look like:

30 x Manual Citations = $90
Duplicate Removal = $18
Local Data Aggregators (x 5) = $100
Total = $208 (one-off payment)
Yext offers four plans, starting at $199 a year.

Emerging Plan – $199/yr
The ‘Emerging’ Yext plan includes listings on MerchantCircle, ELocal and 30 other non-premium websites.

Essential Plan – $499/yr
The ‘Essential’ Yext plan includes listings on key sites, including Facebook, Google, Yelp, and more.

Complete Plan – $499/yr
The ‘Complete’ plan includes the full ‘Emerging’ and ‘Essential’ packages alongside PowerListings+ and Analytics.

Premium Plan – $999/yr
The ‘Premium’ Yext plan contains everything from the other three packages, plus Review Monitoring and Yext Pages.